Modern Orthodox

Written by Daniel Goldfarb
Directed by James Lapine

In this snappy romantic comedy awash in culture-clash conflicts, Hershel, a young modern Orthodox diamond dealer, invades the lives of a secular Jewish couple, Ben and Hannah. They are provoked to question their commitment to each other and the depth of their religious feeling.

Modern Orthodox

Off-Broadway at New World Stages Stage III (Dodger Stages)
December 06, 2004 - May 8, 2005‍ ‍

  • Daniel Goldfarb, Playwright

    James Lapine, Director

    Ars Nova, Producer

    Kara Medoff, Producer

    Jewcy, Produced in Association

    Underwood Theater, Produced in Association

    Amanda Lipitz, Associate Producer

    Greg Smith, Associate Producer

    Michael Stern, Associate Producer

    Marjorie Stern, Associate Producer

    Derek McLane, Set Designer

    Dona Granata, Costume Designer

    David Lander, Lighting Designer

    Fitz Patton, Sound Designer

    Stuart Thompson Productions, General Manager

    James Triner, General Manager

    Barlow/Hartman Public Relations, Press Representative

    Carol Fineman, Press Representative

    Jane Grey, Production Stage Manager

    Dan Shaheen, Stage Manager

    Kai Brothers, Production Manager

    David Caparelliotis, Casting

  • Craig Bierko: Ben Jacobson

    Jason Biggs: Hershel Klein

    Jenn Harris: Rachel Feinberger

    Molly Ringwald: Hannah Ziggelstein


    Understudies: Sandy Rustin (Hannah/Rachel), Peter Smith (Ben/Hershel)


    Replacements: Sarah Chalke (for Hannah), Hunter Foster (for Ben) and John Cariani (for Hershel)

Reviews & Features

“The gags may be parceled out with the mechanical rhythms of a sitcom script, a flaw the skilled director James Lapine smoothly disguises, but they are often sharp and punchy… and the combined gifts of the cast, which is completed by a quirky newcomer, Jenn Harris, as Hershel's instant fiancée, could give buoyancy to a far flimsier concoction.”

Charles Isherwood for The New York Times, 2004

"There is something to be said for writing about your own heritage… It gives you license to explore darker areas of your culture with humor. Anthropologically, there is a history of this throughout comedy. Our director, James Lapine, is also Jewish… I don't think it's mandatory that the director be Jewish, but it does help if he has a certain awareness of himself as a Jew. Throughout, the two of us were walking a thin line between being biting and being affectionate. We were very careful not to point at Orthodox Jews and say, 'Look at them.' Instead, we're including ourselves in the 'them.' "

Daniel Goldfarb as quoted in 'Jewtopia' and 'Modern Orthodox': Treading the Line”, Backstage Magazine